切换至 "中华医学电子期刊资源库"

中华结直肠疾病电子杂志 ›› 2021, Vol. 10 ›› Issue (05) : 457 -461. doi: 10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-3224.2021.05.002

述评

随机对照临床试验在外科中的局限性
王锡山1,()   
  1. 1. 100021 北京,国家癌症中心/国家肿瘤临床医学研究中心/中国医学科学院北京协和医学院肿瘤医院结直肠外科
  • 收稿日期:2021-08-15 出版日期:2021-10-25
  • 通信作者: 王锡山
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金面上项目(82072732); 北京市科技计划(D171100002617004)

Limitations of randomized controlled trial in surgery

Xishan Wang1,()   

  1. 1. Department of Colorectal Surgery, National Cancer Center/National Clinical Research Center for Cancer/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing 100021, China
  • Received:2021-08-15 Published:2021-10-25
  • Corresponding author: Xishan Wang
引用本文:

王锡山. 随机对照临床试验在外科中的局限性[J]. 中华结直肠疾病电子杂志, 2021, 10(05): 457-461.

Xishan Wang. Limitations of randomized controlled trial in surgery[J]. Chinese Journal of Colorectal Diseases(Electronic Edition), 2021, 10(05): 457-461.

随机对照临床试验(RCT)作为循证医学最高级别证据,一直被认为是临床证据中的“金标准”。但随着近现代医学的发展,尤其是外科学、外科新技术的不断涌现,RCT的局限性也逐渐暴露出来。本文通过回顾RCT的历史,观察RCT在医学各领域的作用,分析RCT在外科新技术中的局限性,并探讨培训体系的建立在外科新技术的成熟、发展过程中所起到的重要作用,为同道们正确看待RCT抛砖引玉。

Randomized controlled trial (RCT), as the highest level evidence of evidence-based medicine, has always been regarded as the "gold standard" in clinical evidence. However, with the development of modern medicine, especially the emergence of new surgical techniques, the limitations of RCT are gradually exposed. This paper reviews the history of RCT, observes the role of RCT in various fields of medicine, analyzes the limitations of RCT in new surgical technology, and discusses the important role of the establishment of training system in the maturity and development of new surgical technology, so as to throw bricks and jade for colleagues to treat RCT correctly.

[1]
Wilkinson L. Sir Austin Bradford Hill: medical statistics and the quantitative approach to prevention of disease[J]. Addiction, 1997, 92(6): 657-666.
[2]
Nowak D. Vitamin C in human health and disease[J]. Nutrients, 2021, 13(5): 1595.
[3]
Donaldson IM. The 'bloody Moloch': Osler and van Helmont on bloodletting[J]. J R Coll Physicians Edinb, 2017, 47(2): 196-204.
[4]
Lawrence RE, Appelbaum PS, Lieberman JA. A historical review of placebo-controlled, relapse prevention trials in schizophrenia: the loss of clinical equipoise[J]. Schizophr Res, 2021, 229: 122-131.
[5]
Stamm JW. The classic caries clinical trial: constraints and opportunities[J]. J Dent Res, 2004, 83 Spec No C: C6-14.
[6]
Hanna L. Thalidomide's long and winding road[J]. BETA, 1998 Apr: 33-35, 42.
[7]
Nahian A, Wadhwa R. Federal regulation of medication production. 2021 Jun 20. In: StatPearls[OL]. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing, 2021 Jan.
[8]
Evidence-based medicine working group. Evidence-based medicine. A new approach to teaching the practice of medicine[J]. JAMA, 1992, 268(17): 2420-2425.
[9]
Bothwell LE, Greene JA, Podolsky SH, et al. Assessing the gold standard-lessons from the history of RCTs[J]. N Engl J Med, 2016, 374(22): 2175-2181.
[10]
Dalton HJ, Berg RA, Nadkarni VM, et al. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation and rescue therapies[J]. Crit Care Med, 2021, 49(9): 1375-1388.
[11]
Heald RJ, Ryall RD. Recurrence and survival after total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer[J]. Lancet, 1986, 1(8496): 1479-1482.
[12]
MacFarlane JK, Ryall RD, Heald RJ. Mesorectal excision for rectal cancer[J]. Lancet, 1993, 341(8843): 457-460.
[13]
Heald RJ. Total mesorectal excision is optimal surgery for rectal cancer: a Scandinavian consensus[J]. Br J Surg, 1995, 82(10): 1297-1299.
[14]
姜军. 胃大部切除术保留幽门功能术式的研究进展[J]. 消化外科, 2002, 1(6): 393-395.
[15]
曾子杨, 孙娟, 康维明. 减重代谢手术的历史、现状与展望[J]. 中国医学科学院学报, 2018, 40(5): 581-590.
[16]
吕平, 刘芳, 戚昭恩. 腹腔镜外科百年发展史[J]. 中华医史杂志, 2001, 31(4): 217-220.
[17]
Van Oostendorp SE, Belgers HJE, Hol JC, et al. The learning curve of transanal total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer is associated with local recurrence: results from a multicentre external audit[J]. Colorectal Dis, 2021, 23(8): 2020-2029.
[1] 刘荫华. 中国乳腺外科临床实践——共识与争议[J]. 中华乳腺病杂志(电子版), 2022, 16(04): 262-262.
[2] 龙天柱, 姚育芝, 罗家月, 蔡媛璇, 梁震, 樊哲, 朱彩荣, 潘玉鸿, 马宏民. 哺乳期乳腺脓肿抗生素治疗的回顾性研究[J]. 中华乳腺病杂志(电子版), 2021, 15(04): 214-217.
[3] 中华医学会骨科学分会关节外科学组, 云南省创伤骨科临床医学中心(解放军联勤保障部队第九二〇医院). 中国髋关节置换入路选择临床实践指南(2021年版)[J]. 中华关节外科杂志(电子版), 2021, 15(06): 651-659.
[4] 赵翔宇, 李晖菲, 张芳, 任秀云, 王兴. SPOC翻转课堂在口腔颌面外科临床检查教学中的应用初探[J]. 中华口腔医学研究杂志(电子版), 2022, 16(02): 118-124.
[5] 阮永同, 陈光耀, 谭健秋, 黄秋宝, 梁健峰. 经腹腹腔镜下右肾周筋膜解剖研究及其在腹腔镜右肾切除中应用价值[J]. 中华腔镜泌尿外科杂志(电子版), 2020, 14(02): 106-111.
[6] 任成山, 林辉, 杨仕明. 循证医学应用中临床经验的重要性[J]. 中华肺部疾病杂志(电子版), 2020, 13(03): 293-296.
[7] 刘骞. 直肠癌侧方淋巴结清扫中国临床开展的现状[J]. 中华结直肠疾病电子杂志, 2022, 11(05): 367-371.
[8] 薛庆云, 赵立连, 徐旭阳, 郑其开, 傅志俭, 张元民, 王延秀, 熊晓扬, 许亚男, 石磊, 王飞. 奇正消痛贴膏治疗渐冻期冻结肩的多中心随机对照临床试验[J]. 中华肩肘外科电子杂志, 2021, 09(04): 352-359.
[9] 郑颖, 孟金铃, 蔡广研, 冯哲. 混合式教学模式在肾脏病学专业学位研究生循证医学课程中的实践与思考[J]. 中华肾病研究电子杂志, 2023, 12(01): 48-50.
[10] 江基尧. 中国颅脑创伤诊治的未来[J]. 中华神经创伤外科电子杂志, 2019, 05(05): 257-259.
[11] 康庆林. 临床实践与体会能够促进骨外科学事业发展[J]. 中华老年骨科与康复电子杂志, 2023, 09(05): 257-262.
[12] 吴宗盛, 谢剑锋, 邱海波. 2021版拯救脓毒症运动指南:早期复苏的八大“陷阱”[J]. 中华重症医学电子杂志, 2023, 09(01): 14-18.
[13] 赵继宗. 神经外科学创新发展愿景[J]. 中华脑科疾病与康复杂志(电子版), 2022, 12(05): 257-259.
[14] 严楠, 杜丽雪, 依斯坎德尔·依沙江, 宋美娜, 王非, 王仲. 医疗决策中的循证与叙事依据[J]. 中华临床医师杂志(电子版), 2022, 16(11): 1142-1145.
[15] 王晓玲, 杨婷, 尹专叶, 张颖. 脑卒中后抑郁状态识别与预防的最佳证据总结[J]. 中华脑血管病杂志(电子版), 2023, 17(01): 51-56.
阅读次数
全文


摘要